Can businesses negotiate uncertain damages?
In tenBraak v. Waffle Shops, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the proposition that commercial leases could provide for the recovery of future rents even though such recovery was not available under the common law. It seemed the attitude of the court was to permit businesses to negotiate their respective default rights. After all, the actual losses to the landlord when the default takes place are very difficult to determine, and the landlord should not have to spend a lot of money litigating damages when the parties have agreed to a formula. When the Virginia Supreme Court addressed several cases involving acceleration provisions in commercial leases, they upheld by implication the principle that these clauses were enforceable. Unfortunately, no case on appeal has clearly and unequivocally found that these clauses can be enforced, even if the amount required to be paid would exceed the actual damages suffered by the Landlord.
Are acceleration damages a penalty?
In the Fairfax County Circuit Court case of Teachers Retirement Sys. v. American Title Guar., Judge Thomas S. Kenny struck down an acceleration clause as unenforceable because "it calls for damages in excess of Plaintiff's actual damages." Judge Kenny under the facts of the case deemed the acceleration sums sought to be a "potential windfall" and an "unenforceable penalty." Judge Kenny indicated that the landlord's actual damages was the difference between the amount that should have been paid by the tenant and the amount of rent actually collected if the premises is relet, plus cost associated with reletting. However, the lease was so poorly drafted that Judge Kenny declined to rewrite the lease in order to provide some amount for future losses caused by the default. Thus, the landlord received no award for future damages.
Practical Advice
Mandatory acceleration provisions or damages grossly in excess of actual losses will be problematic. The remedies portion of the Lease needs to be carefully crafted to permit the landlord several options in the event of default. If the losses will be uncertain and difficult to ascertain, then the entire lease should support the proposition that an advance stipulation of damages is needed. The Lease could contain a provision which requires an independent appraiser to set the amount of damages, whose decision would be difficult to dispute.
When attempting to obtain a judgment after default, the landlord should calculate realistic actual and projected losses. If such a calculation is not possible, it may be better to utilize Virginia Code §8.01-128 which permits a landlord to evict a tenant without losing the right to recover for any later deficiency in rent after making an effort to minimize the damages by renting to another tenant; under this statute a landlord can come back to court for later judgments as the damages accrue.
Final Advice
The above is not meant to replace legal counsel. Have a Landlord/Tenant lawyer draft or review all commercial leases. To speak to an attorney, please contact Gross & Romanick directly by calling 703-273-1400 or filling out their online form.
FAIRFAX LAWYERS KEEP YOU UPDATED ON DC METRO LAWS
A SERVICE OF GROSS, ROMANICK, DEAN & DESIMONE, P.C.
Showing posts with label fairfax attorney. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fairfax attorney. Show all posts
Monday, March 2, 2009
Monday, January 12, 2009
The Statute of Frauds: It's Not What it Sounds Like (What you should put in writing)
Based on its name you might think that the Statute of Frauds has something to do with criminal or civil fraud, but it doesn't. The name "Statute of Frauds" actually refers to a law passed by the British Parliament in 1677, and the name has been retained through the centuries. It specifies which kinds of contracts must be in writing in order to be enforceable. Its purpose is to prevent the setting up of supposed agreements and then supporting them by perjury.
The most common applications of the Statute of Frauds are as follows:
* Holding a person responsible for the promise to pay the debt of another
* Contracts for the sale of real estate
* Leases for real estate over 1 year
* Agreements which cannot be performed within 1 year
* Sale of personal property over $5,000
* Sale of goods over $500, unless the buyer accepts the goods
* Agency agreements
While the Statute requires a written agreement, almost any writing sufficient to indicate some kind of agreement between the parties will suffice. However, the "writing" must be signed by the party who is being charged. Thus, the venerable Statute of Frauds is still an important and influential part of modern law.
***
The above article is not meant to replace legal counsel. To speak to one of Gross & Romanick's attorneys please contact them directly by filling out their online form, email them at law@gross.com, or call (703) 273-1400.
The most common applications of the Statute of Frauds are as follows:
* Holding a person responsible for the promise to pay the debt of another
* Contracts for the sale of real estate
* Leases for real estate over 1 year
* Agreements which cannot be performed within 1 year
* Sale of personal property over $5,000
* Sale of goods over $500, unless the buyer accepts the goods
* Agency agreements
While the Statute requires a written agreement, almost any writing sufficient to indicate some kind of agreement between the parties will suffice. However, the "writing" must be signed by the party who is being charged. Thus, the venerable Statute of Frauds is still an important and influential part of modern law.
***
The above article is not meant to replace legal counsel. To speak to one of Gross & Romanick's attorneys please contact them directly by filling out their online form, email them at law@gross.com, or call (703) 273-1400.
Monday, January 5, 2009
Tenancy by the Entirety: Another Reason to Say "I Do"
The ancient Common Law considered a husband and wife to be one person for purposes of property ownership. Both husband and wife were held to have a "tenancy by the entirety" in all the property that they jointly owned. Modern Virginia law has largely abandoned this characterization of a married couple as a single legal entity, but the peculiar legal arrangement of tenancy by the entirety still exists.
If husband and wife hold property in a tenancy by the entirety, the joint property is completely immune to the claims of a creditor of one spouse alone. Only a creditor of both husband and wife may subject the property to a lien or judgment. Virginia law allows virtually any kind of property to be held as a tenancy by the entirety, not just real estate. In the case of Pitts v. U.S., the U.S. 4th Circuit Court of Appeals held that the proceeds of a sale of real estate which was held by a tenancy by the entireties are likewise considered to be held by the entireties, even if the proceeds are in some form other than cash, such as deed of trust note.
Joint bank accounts are governed by special rules that do not recognize a tenancy by the entirety per se but do afford some protection to married couples. Virginia law presumes that joint bank accounts are divided equally between husband and wife, even if one spouse has deposited a substantially greater amount than the other. This means that a creditor of a single spouse generally can only assert a claim against one half of the amount in the joint account, even if the other spouse has deposited much more in the account.
***
The above is not meant to replace legal counsel. To speak with an attorney, contact Gross & Romanick directly by filling out their online form, emailing law@gross.com or calling (703) 273-1400.
If husband and wife hold property in a tenancy by the entirety, the joint property is completely immune to the claims of a creditor of one spouse alone. Only a creditor of both husband and wife may subject the property to a lien or judgment. Virginia law allows virtually any kind of property to be held as a tenancy by the entirety, not just real estate. In the case of Pitts v. U.S., the U.S. 4th Circuit Court of Appeals held that the proceeds of a sale of real estate which was held by a tenancy by the entireties are likewise considered to be held by the entireties, even if the proceeds are in some form other than cash, such as deed of trust note.
Joint bank accounts are governed by special rules that do not recognize a tenancy by the entirety per se but do afford some protection to married couples. Virginia law presumes that joint bank accounts are divided equally between husband and wife, even if one spouse has deposited a substantially greater amount than the other. This means that a creditor of a single spouse generally can only assert a claim against one half of the amount in the joint account, even if the other spouse has deposited much more in the account.
***
The above is not meant to replace legal counsel. To speak with an attorney, contact Gross & Romanick directly by filling out their online form, emailing law@gross.com or calling (703) 273-1400.
Monday, December 29, 2008
Prebankruptcy Provisions: Should you include them in your contracts?
Creditors and lending institutions have recently been including various provisions in their contracts and credit agreements, which contemplate what will happen in the event of a bankruptcy. The provisions can be divided into three basic categories: (1) Waivers; (2) Covenants; and, (3) Representations/Admissions.
Waivers limit a borrower's right to either file a bankruptcy petition or to oppose the creditor's lifting of the automatic stay. Covenants provide for immediate relief from the automatic stay or consent not to contest a lift stay motion. Representations/Admissions include provisions in the agreement which admit the elements necessary for the creditor to lift the automatic stay, admit that any future bankruptcy filing will be made in bad faith to hinder or delay the creditor and admissions that security interests are properly perfected.
The prebankruptcy waivers provide a comfort level to lenders and creditors in the hope that they will not be delayed or damaged in the event of bankruptcy and they also are put in agreements to provide assurances that they are avoiding deals with debtors heading toward bankruptcy.
The courts are split on the enforcement of the prebankruptcy provisions. Some courts have expressed concern as to whether or not the provisions violate public policy. In almost all cases however, the courts have found the agreements are not necessarily self-executing. Therefore, a creditor should be weary of taking any action, which may result in a violation of the automatic stay without first obtaining bankruptcy court approval.
On the positive side, prebankruptcy provisions have proven to speed up the process and assist creditors in obtaining quick relief from the automatic stay of bankruptcy. In addition, some courts have upheld the various admissions and representations as conclusive evidence of the elements needed to lift the stay. This has led to a decrease in litigation cost for some creditors.
It would be dangerous and unadvisable to take any action which may be determined to be a violation of the automatic stay in reliance on the prebankruptcy provisions, but including the provisions may save you litigation fees in the long run. Therefore, while prebankruptcy provisions are not guaranteed to work, you may want to include them in your agreements.
The above article is not meant to replace legal counsel. If you'd like to speak to an attorney, please contact Gross & Romanick directly by filling out their online form, e-mailing law@gross.com, or calling (703) 273-1400.
Waivers limit a borrower's right to either file a bankruptcy petition or to oppose the creditor's lifting of the automatic stay. Covenants provide for immediate relief from the automatic stay or consent not to contest a lift stay motion. Representations/Admissions include provisions in the agreement which admit the elements necessary for the creditor to lift the automatic stay, admit that any future bankruptcy filing will be made in bad faith to hinder or delay the creditor and admissions that security interests are properly perfected.
The prebankruptcy waivers provide a comfort level to lenders and creditors in the hope that they will not be delayed or damaged in the event of bankruptcy and they also are put in agreements to provide assurances that they are avoiding deals with debtors heading toward bankruptcy.
The courts are split on the enforcement of the prebankruptcy provisions. Some courts have expressed concern as to whether or not the provisions violate public policy. In almost all cases however, the courts have found the agreements are not necessarily self-executing. Therefore, a creditor should be weary of taking any action, which may result in a violation of the automatic stay without first obtaining bankruptcy court approval.
On the positive side, prebankruptcy provisions have proven to speed up the process and assist creditors in obtaining quick relief from the automatic stay of bankruptcy. In addition, some courts have upheld the various admissions and representations as conclusive evidence of the elements needed to lift the stay. This has led to a decrease in litigation cost for some creditors.
It would be dangerous and unadvisable to take any action which may be determined to be a violation of the automatic stay in reliance on the prebankruptcy provisions, but including the provisions may save you litigation fees in the long run. Therefore, while prebankruptcy provisions are not guaranteed to work, you may want to include them in your agreements.
The above article is not meant to replace legal counsel. If you'd like to speak to an attorney, please contact Gross & Romanick directly by filling out their online form, e-mailing law@gross.com, or calling (703) 273-1400.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)