FAIRFAX LAWYERS KEEP YOU UPDATED ON DC METRO LAWS


A SERVICE OF GROSS, ROMANICK, DEAN & DESIMONE, P.C.

Showing posts with label commercial landlord law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commercial landlord law. Show all posts

Thursday, October 1, 2009

Buildout Allowance

FACTS: The tenant leased a property from a commercial Landlord. Part of the lease agreement was a building allowance of $699,000 to be paid by the Landlord for improvements. The tenant hired a contractor to do the improvements to the property. The Contractor accidentally demolished an unoccupied improvement on the property. Upon noticing their mistake the same day, the Contractor offered to remedy by either rebuilding the improvements or allowing for a credit for the value of the improvements. Instead of accepting one of the offered remedies the Landlord decided to withhold $301,000 of the tenant's allowance. When the tenant and the contractor sued for the allowance, the landlord counter-claimed for lost rent and replacement of the improvement even though the Landlord did not have a tenant for the demolished space and did not replace the demolished improvement.

COURT RULING: The Court determined that the Landlord's counter-claims were without merit; and that the Landlord and its counsel should have known of the meritless nature of the claim. Judgment was entered against the Landlord for $351,057.65 for the withheld allowance plus interest. The Court also sanctioned the Landlord the sum of $251,018.16 for attorney's fees and costs for the baseless counter-claim and defenses, which prolonged the litigation (Va. Code § 8.01-271.1).

ACTION ADVISE: A building allowance is an enforceable right of the tenant. If the landlord withholds payment for the allowance, it will need good cause to do so. Furthermore, if a landlord does not have a tenant for the demolished or damaged space, it should not withhold a building allowance on the basis of lost rent. If the landlord has no intention of rebuilding the damaged improvements, the landlord is not acting in good faith by charging the contractor for the repair cost. Finally, asserting baseless claims in a court proceeding can result in sanctions. Try to resolve these disputes out of court!

***

The above is not meant to replace legal counsel. If you'd like to speak to one of the lawyers at Gross & Romanick about a similar case, fill out their online request form or call 703-273-1400.

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

Building Manager Liable for Theft of Tenant's Property

In Virginia it is rare that a landlord or property manager is found responsible for third party criminal acts against tenants. Nevertheless, in the 2002 Arlington County Circuit Court case of King v. Atrium Unit Owners Association, a jury found a building manager liable for the burglary of a tenant's condominium.

Facts: While on vacation, a tenant left the key to her condo with a building manager. Circumstantial evidence satisfied the jury that the burglar used the key left with the building manager to steal $250,000 worth of property.

Finding: The building manager was negligent in the custodianship of the key.

Advice: Landlords, building managers and property managers must protect tenant keys, master keys and access codes that will permit access to tenant's premises. Negligent handling of such keys or access codes may result in liability for thefts.

For more information about commercial landlord law or to seek legal representation, contact Gross & Romanick today.

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

Residential Versus Commercial Tenants

Gross & Romanick publishes a number of articles on their website about their various practice areas: Bankruptcy; Business Law; Commercial Landlord; Construction Law; Litigation; Personal Injury; Technology Law; and Traffic/DWI.

Here’s an article from the Commercial Landlord section:


Residential and Commercial Tenants: Do Not Treat Them the Same!

All leases are not created equal. Commercial leases are generally governed by the specific terms of the lease agreement between landlord and tenant, but Virginia law automatically merges certain statutory terms into every residential lease. The Virginia Residential Landlord Tenant Act gives residential tenants considerably more rights than are afforded to commercial tenants.

Evictions

The differences between residential and commercial leases are most starkly apparent when a landlord attempts to evict a defaulting tenant. Commercial landlords have rights of self-help; they can, under proper circumstances, simply lockout non-paying tenants (as long as this is done with great care - see Edward Gross Report, Spring 1992). Residential landlords, however, have no such remedy. The Virginia Code Section §55.248.36 provides that "Landlord may not refuse to permit tenant access to a unit unless refusal is pursuant to a court order." Furthermore, a residential landlord is also forbidden from denying essential services to his tenant, such water, heat, or electricity, in an effort to force out that tenant. Residential tenant must be served with a 5 day "pay or quit" notice before eviction, but no such notice is required for commercial tenants (we recommend serving notice on both types of tenants).

Duty to Maintain

A commercial landlord has no duty to maintain the premises during the lease term; repairs are the responsibility of the tenant. Of course, both commercial landlords and tenants can, and often do, specifically contract to impose a duty to repair upon the landlord, but no such duty is implied in law. Conversely, the Virginia Residential Landlord Tenant Act imposes a specific affirmative duty on every residential landlord to maintain and repair the premises throughout the term of the lease. A residential landlord must keep all common areas in a clean and safe condition, must maintain all plumbing and heating, sanitary facilities, and any appliances on the premises. A residential landlord also has a general obligation to keep the premises in a "fit and habitable" condition. These duties can be transferred to the tenant, but the transfer must be in writing and done for a "good faith" purpose (something other than just an attempt by the landlord to evade his obligations).

Security Deposits

In commercial settings, the amount and disposition of security deposits are generally governed by provisions of the lease. The lease will spell out for what purposes it can be used by the landlord, and when and how the security deposit is to be returned to the tenant. Residential landlords, on the other hand, must comply with Section §55-248.11 of the Act, which provides detailed procedures and rules governing the use of residential security deposits. Among its provisions, the Act mandates that a residential security deposit cannot exceed more than two month's rent; and the landlord must provide interest at five percent per anum payable to the tenant upon termination of the lease (if the deposit is kept for over thirteen months).

The residential landlord may apply the security deposit only to the payment of accrued rent (with attendant late charges), and to offset damage to the premises caused by the tenant. The landlord must inspect the premises for damage within 72 hours from the time the tenant vacates, and the tenant has a right to be present during the inspection. After making deductions for damage, the landlord must return the remaining portion of the security deposit within thirty days after the termination of the tenancy, along with a written itemization of the damages to which the deposit was applied. If the landlord fails to comply with any of these provisions, the tenant may recover from the landlord the security deposit plus any actual damages and reasonable attorney's fees.

In the Fall, 1991 edition of the Edward Gross Report, an article discussed the possibility of losing a security deposit after foreclosure. In fact, this only applies to commercial tenants because Virginia Code Section §55-248.11 states: "The holder of the Landlord's interest at the time of termination of tenancy regardless of how that interest is acquired or transferred...shall be required to return any security deposit received by the original Landlord."