FAIRFAX LAWYERS KEEP YOU UPDATED ON DC METRO LAWS


A SERVICE OF GROSS, ROMANICK, DEAN & DESIMONE, P.C.

Showing posts with label business law fairfax. Show all posts
Showing posts with label business law fairfax. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 28, 2016

Does an Employer Have the Right to Access an Employee’s Personal E-mail Account to Review Work-Related Emails?

In Virginia, it is settled that an employer can legally monitor and review e-mails of an employee communicated through the employer’s e-mail server or e-mail accounts.  It is also settled that an employer can legally monitor and review any personal communications that are stored on company-owned equipment, such as computers and cellphones. In both scenarios, the courts have ruled that employees have no reasonable expectation of privacy with respect to such communications. It is less settled whether an employer can legally review work-related e-mails sent or received by an employee through a personal e-mail account.

A recent case out of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Virginia tackled this very issue.  In the case of Hoofnagle v. Smyth-Wythe Airport Commission, et al., the plaintiff alleged that his employer violated his rights under the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and the Stored Communications Act (18 U.S.C. § 2701, et al.) when, after his employment was terminated, the employer accessed his e-mail account to review work-related e-mails. The plaintiff had been employed as the manager of a small regional airport. Since his employer did not maintain any e-mail accounts for its business, the plaintiff created a Yahoo! e-mail account that he used for both business and personal purposes. He was terminated after sending the following e-mail to Senator Timothy Kaine:

Dear, Mr. Kain [sic]. I own over 9 AR platform rifles and 30 some various other rifles and shotguns, a dozen handguns, I suggest you stick up for rights of all gun owners in Va. In my opinion you and your kind (Liberals) ARE a CANCER to this state and COUNTRY, therefore I have gone to the voting polls every Nov. to try and eradicate you and your kind from public office, and will continue to do so. We do not have a gun problem, We have an IDIOT PROBLEM, go deal with that, and not the competent gun owner. Here is the Va. NRA tollfree # 1-800-672-3888. Now you can join the NRA. So you can be apart [sic] of something with some substance and character…Charles H. Hoofnagle. Airport Operations Manager Mt. Empire Airport in south west Va. 276-685-1122 

In response to the lawsuit, the employer filed a motion for summary judgment, which was granted as to the Fourth Amendment claim (since the search was deemed reasonable), but denied as to the Stored Communications Act (SCA) claim. The Court opined that e-mails stored on the server of an internet service provider (ISP) like Yahoo! are subject to the SCA, and that if the employer accessed the e-mails by directly logging into the ISP website without the authorization of the employee, then such action would constitute a violation of the SCA (regardless of whether the employee used the employer’s computer to send the communications). By denying the employer’s motion for summary judgment, the Court allowed the plaintiff to pursue the SCA claim through trial, with the trial issue clearly being: did the employee give the account password to his employer, thereby authorizing access? The court did conclude that if the e-mail communications had been stored on a work computer, as opposed to on the ISP server, then the e-mails would not have been protected by the SCA. 

This case illustrates that it is important for employers to adopt a technology policy that expressly communicates to each employee, at a minimum, that: (a) the employer is authorized to monitor all work-related emails; (b) the employee has no expectation of privacy in work-related e-mails; (c) the employee has no expectation of privacy in materials stored on employer-owned equipment; (d) the employee shall not access personal e-mail accounts from employer-owned equipment; and (e) the employee shall not send work-related e-mails from personal e-mail accounts. This case also illustrates that it is important for employers to issue business e-mail accounts to all employees, and to require employees to provide account passwords.

The attorneys at Gross & Romanick, P.C. have substantial experience drafting employee handbooks and related policies designed to protect business owners.

Distinguishing Non-Solicit Agreements from Non-Compete Agreements

Employers are justifiably concerned with protecting their businesses from competition with former employees. This is generally accomplished by requiring employees to sign agreements containing restrictive covenants. The two types of restrictive covenants that are most often utilized by employers are (1) non-solicit covenants and (2) non-compete covenants.  These two types of restrictive covenants are often blurred together, but they are distinctly different, and Virginia Courts recognize the distinction when the covenants are challenged. 

The purpose of a non-compete covenant is to prevent the former employee from generally competing with the employer in the same industry. The purpose of a non-solicit covenant is to prevent the former employee from providing services to the employer’s clients and/or hiring away the employer’s other employees.  In Virginia, non-solicit covenants are considered a species of non-compete covenants, and the same legal standard of enforceability applies to each. Since both types of covenants create a restraint on trade, neither covenant is favored in Virginia.  In all cases, a Court will evaluate the covenant in light of the circumstances of the businesses and employees involved in order to determine whether the covenant is necessary to protect the employer’s “legitimate” business interests, taking into consideration the restricted activities (i.e. the “function”), the geographic scope, and the duration of the covenant. The employer bears the burden to show that the restraint is no greater than necessary to protect a legitimate business interest, is not unduly harsh or oppressive in curtailing an employee’s ability to earn a livelihood, and is reasonable in light of sound public policy. 

While the same legal standard of enforceability applies to both types of covenants, case law shows us that Virginia Courts are more likely to enforce non-solicit covenants than they are to enforce non-compete covenants. The obvious reason is that preventing a former employee from directly poaching the employer’s existing client base and/or employees is more likely to protect that employer’s business interests than preventing the former employee from simply working for a competitor or competing for new business on the open market.  See, for example, Leddy v. Communication Consultants, Inc., 51 Va. Cir. 467 (Virginia Beach 2000), in which the Court affirmed a two year non-solicit agreement and noted that a non-solicit covenant is typically narrower in application than a non-compete covenant because it does not restrict the employee from working for a competitor.  

Even so, like non-compete covenants, non-solicit covenants must be narrowly tailored in duration and scope in order to be enforceable in Virginia. For example, in ManTech Int’l Corp. v. Analex Corp., 75 Va. Cir. 354 (Fairfax 2008), the Court struck down a six month non-solicit covenant as overbroad and ambiguous finding the phrase “the Employee shall not directly or indirectly solicit or induce any employees of ManTech to leave the employ of Mantech” not narrowly tailored to protect a legitimate business interest and unenforceable, per se, since it conceivably covers situations in which one employee convinces another to retire early, join the military or move to another state. Similarly, in Lasership, Inc. v. Watson, 79 Va. Cir. 205 (Fairfax 2009), the Court found the following two-year non-solicit covenant to be unenforceable since it prevented the employee from pursing non-competitive employment positions: “Employee shall not, for himself or on behalf of any other person, firm, corporation, or other entity, contact in any manner, directly or indirectly, solicit, agree to perform or perform any services of any type that the Company can render…for any of the Company’s Customers.”

Conversely, in Daston Corp. V. MiCore Solutions, 80 Va. Cir. 611 (Fairfax 2010), the Court upheld the enforceability of two-year non-solicit that was no broader than necessary to meet the company’s legitimate business interest.  The plain language of the covenant applied only to a “fixed universe of customers, namely those that existed during the employee’s term of employment”, a list of customers that was known to the employees being restrained, as compared to Lasership, which restriction imposed an “unreasonable burden” on the former employee to know the customers it could not solicit. 

With respect to the duration of the non-solicit covenant, there is no clear marker to distinguish enforceability.  One-year non-solicit covenants have been routinely upheld, and two-year non-solicit covenants have also been upheld with some regularity. Including a longer duration seems problematic under existing Virginia case law, and is not recommended as a practice pointer, although in 2012 the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia concluded that a five year non-solicit agreement can be reasonable under Virginia law. See Capital One Fin. Corp. v. Kanas, 871 F. Supp. 2d 520.  However, a key consideration made by the Court in that matter was the nature of the business (insurance), the Court determining that the restricted period was directly related to an important element of the business (policy renewals).  

In conclusion, a non-solicit covenant is more likely to be enforced in Virginia than a non-compete covenant, even though the same legal standard applies to the Court’s analysis.  However, like non-compete covenants, non-solicit covenants must be narrowly tailored and explicitly backed up by a specific legitimate business purpose that justifies the functional restrictions and the length of the restrictive term.

Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Letters of Credit

Letters of credit have been in use for over two thousand years, in one form or another. From the time of ancient Greece and Rome up through the present, letters of credit have been mainly used to finance shipping contracts. However, letters of credit have uses that go far beyond just transportation. In a letter of credit arrangement, the issuing party, usually a bank or insurance company, contracts with one party to pay funds to a third party upon the fulfillment of certain conditions specified in the agreement. Most commonly, they are employed to finance a sale of goods where the buyer and seller have limited contact and experience with each other, such as an international transaction. Because letters of credit are employed so extensively in international trade, they are governed by an international treaty ("Uniform Customs and Practices Governing Documentary Credits"). But utility of letters of credit is not confined to international shipping; they can be quite useful right here in Virginia. A tenant can obtain a letter of credit which will become payable to the landlord upon a certification from the landlord that the tenant has defaulted on his rent. This arrangement has several advantages over a conventional security deposit. The landlord can demand a much larger security deposit in the form of a standby letter of credit than he could in cash, and the tenant does not have to use his valuable cash reserves to satisfy the security deposit, assuming the tenant has a reliable credit history. In addition, the tenant will not be at risk of losing his security deposit if a foreclosure occurs. *** The above is not meant to replace legal counsel. If you'd like to speak to one of the lawyers at Gross & Romanick, please call us at 703-273-1400 or fill out our online information request form.

Monday, December 5, 2011

The Americans with Disabilities Act and Reasonable Accommodations

The Americans with Disabilities Act (the “ADA”) was enacted into law by Congress in 1990. Title I of the ADA prevents employers from discriminating against a person with a disability, on the basis of that disability, with respect to job application procedures, hiring, advancement, discharge, compensation and other terms or conditions of employment. In 2008, after a series of U.S. Supreme Court decisions narrowed the definition of a “disability” so as to significantly limit the scope of the ADA, Congress passed the ADA Amendments Act. The purpose of the ADAAA was to broaden the definition of “disability” and thus provide coverage to a wider group of individuals.

The term “disability” means, with respect to an individual, a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more of the “major life activities” of such individual. “Major life activities” include, but are not limited to, caring for oneself, performing manual tasks, seeing, hearing, eating, sleeping, walking, standing, lifting, bending, speaking, breathing, learning, reading, concentrating, thinking, communicating and working.

The ADA requires an employer with 15 or more employees to provide “reasonable accommodation” for individuals with disabilities. A “reasonable accommodation” is any change in the work environment, or in the way things are customarily done, that enables an individual with a disability to enjoy equal employment opportunities. A reasonable accommodation need not be provided if it would impose an “undue hardship” on the operation of the business of the employer. However, an employer may not refuse to provide an accommodation just because it involves some cost. Examples of reasonable accommodations include the following:

› making existing facilities accessible;
› part-time or modified work schedules;
› reassignment to a vacant position
› acquiring or modifying equipment; and
› changing tests, training materials, or policies.

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

A Summary Explanation of the Doctrine of Charitable Immunity

Charitable immunity is perhaps one of the most misunderstood concepts in the law. Many charities are under the mistaken assumption that they are immune from any lawsuit simply because they operate as a non-profit and for a charitable purpose. This is a misunderstanding that can have unfortunate consequences.

In Virginia, “[a] charitable institution is immune from liability to its beneficiaries for [ordinary] negligence arising from acts of its servants and agents, but only if due care has been exercised in their selection and retention.” Ola v. YMCA of South Hampton Roads, Inc., 270 Va. 550 (2005). This statement obviously merits further analysis.

First, in order to obtain charitable immunity, the organization must be a charitable institution. To determine whether an institution is charitable, Virginia courts “apply a two-part test, examining (1) whether the organization’s articles of incorporation have a charitable or eleemosynary purpose and (2) whether the organization is in fact operated consistent with that purpose.” Davidson v. The Colonial Williamsburg Found., 817 F.Supp. 611 (E.D. Va. 1993). It is therefore imperative that non-profit organizations operating as charitable or public benefit organizations not only draft articles of incorporation that reflect their mission, but that they also operate in a manner wholly consistent with that mission.

Second, a charitable institution is immune from liability only to its beneficiaries. In Virginia, charities are not immune from liability to legal strangers. A beneficiary is someone that receives something of value, which the organization, through its charitable purposes, undertakes to provide. Egerton v. R.E. Lee Memorial Church, 395 F.2d 381 (4th Cir. 1968). As an example, the recipient of an in-home meal from a charity providing in-home meals to the sick or disabled would be considered a beneficiary of the organization’s charitable purpose. However, the victim of an automobile accident occurring on the roads while the same charity was delivering a meal would not be a beneficiary.

Monday, November 28, 2011

Non-compete Provision - Revisited and Reversed by Virginia Supreme Court

On November 4, 2011, the Virginia Supreme Court issued an important opinion on the enforceability of non-compete agreements in Virginia. In Home Paramount Pest Control Companies, Inc. v. Shaffer, et al., the Supreme Court affirmed the Fairfax County Circuit Court's prior determination that a non-compete provision in a former employee's employment agreement was overbroad and, therefore, unenforceable.

In 1989, in a case involving the same employer, the Supreme Court ruled that an identical provision in an employment agreement was enforceable. Accordingly, the Supreme Court reversed its previous stance, demonstrating the shift in the law that has occurred over the last 22 years. The Supreme Court justified its decision on the basis of several other cases that have been decided since 1989, which cases clarified the law and created the framework from which the 2011 case was decided.

The Supreme Court explained that non-compete provisions are only enforceable if they are narrowly drawn to protect the employer's legitimate business interest, are not unreasonably burdensome on an employee's ability to earn a livelihood and are not against public policy. The employer bears the burden of proving each of these factors. Virginia Courts will consider the function, geographic scope and duration elements of the non-compete when evaluating whether the employer has met its burden. In assessing the "function" element, a Virginia Court will determine whether the prohibited activity is of the same type as that actually engaged in by the former employee while employed by the employer.

Monday, November 21, 2011

The Importance of By-Laws to Resolve Governance Battles

Non-profit organizations need to have a clear governance structure. One reason is that it is not uncommon for the members, officers and/or directors of non-profit organizations to engage in power struggles, particularly if the organization has grown from a small, cohesive group to a larger, loosely organized membership. In some cases, a single member or a small group of members who disagree with the organization’s current management or general objectives can create a significant rift in the organization by publicly denouncing the current administration (or worse, purporting to assert control over the organization). As in any organization, a certain amount of turnover and change can be very positive, but a power struggle may destroy the organization itself. In order to minimize governance battles, the organization’s governing documents need to be strong enough to prevent dissention amongst the members, officers or directors from crippling the organization’s stated purpose (and perhaps, its existence).

The best way to proactively eliminate the risk of organizational anarchy is for the organization to adopt clear, coherent and thorough by-laws. In our experience, many non-profit organizations fail to adopt by-laws with mechanisms designed to provide clear power demarcations and methods for resolution of control issues. In addition, many organizations are using outdated by-laws which were not written for the organization as it is currently structured and operated, or for the technological age, when e-mails and social media can improve communication but can also facilitate membership dissention on a very public platform.

At a minimum, the by-laws of every non-profit organization should clearly set out the following:


Monday, November 17, 2008

The Statute of Frauds: It's Not What it Sounds Like (What you should put in writing)

Based on its name you might think that the Statute of Frauds has something to do with criminal or civil fraud, but it doesn't. The name "Statute of Frauds" actually refers to a law passed by the British Parliament in 1677, and the name has been retained through the centuries. It specifies which kinds of contracts must be in writing in order to be enforceable. Its purpose is to prevent the setting up of supposed agreements and then supporting them by perjury.

The most common applications of the Statute of Frauds are as follows:

* Holding a person responsible for the promise to pay the debt of another
* Contracts for the sale of real estate
* Leases for real estate over 1 year
* Agreements which cannot be performed within 1 year
* Sale of personal property over $5,000
* Sale of goods over $500, unless the buyer accepts the goods
* Agency agreements

While the Statute requires a written agreement, almost any writing sufficient to indicate some kind of agreement between the parties will suffice. However, the "writing" must be signed by the party who is being charged. Thus, the venerable Statute of Frauds is still an important and influential part of modern law.

***

The above article is not meant to replace legal counsel. For legal representation or for questions regarding a specific case, please contact Gross & Romanick directly by filling out their online form, e-mailing law@gross.com or calling 703-273-1400.

Monday, September 22, 2008

At-Will Employment

Here at Gross & Romanick, our business law division is at the heart of our practice and we're dedicated to keeping our clients well-informed and educated about employment law here in VA. Below, you'll find a general discussion of at-will employment in Virginia, but if you're not familiar with the statutes mentioned, its best to seek legal counsel.

***

THE AT-WILL DOCTRINE: In the Commonwealth of Virginia when employees are hired, unless there is a specific contract, they are considered to be at-will employees. This means that the employee may be terminated at any time without notice or reason.

LETTERS OF ENGAGEMENT: Letters of engagement do not form a contract if all they do is state the basic terms and conditions of employment, even if they include items such as benefits, compensation, bonuses, and starting date. To be sure that an engagement letter is not misunderstood by the employee as forming a contract it is important to include a line that states that the employment is for no specific period of time and that the employer is free to terminate the employee at any time.

LAWS TO KNOW: Laws to know are the National Labor Relations Act; the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA); Title VII of the Civil Rights Act as amended in 1991; any state or local anti-discrimination laws; the Age Discrimination in Employment Act; the Americans with Disabilities Act; the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA); the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act; the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act; the Employee Retirement and Income Security Act; the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1985 and many others. Sound overwhelming? It can be. If you ever have any questions regarding your rights under the above laws you should consult your attorney.

EVALUATIONS: It is important to adopt a uniform system of evaluation of your employees for hiring and advancement. These evaluations may be closely scrutinized at a later date if your decisions are challenged by your employees in a discrimination suit.

OVERTIME AND THE FLSA: One of the most overlooked and misinterpreted laws is the FLSA's overtime requirements. When a non-exempt employee works over forty hours in one week that employee is to be paid time and one-half of their regular hourly wage. It is often mistakenly thought that this requirement can be satisfied by awarding the employee compensatory time off. Awarding compensatory time off can only be a substitute in very limited circumstances.

ACTION ADVICE: Most Employers prefer the at-will status and should take care not to change it by letter, contract or handbook. If you are not familiar with the statutes mentioned above, contact an attorney and have them explained to you.

Wednesday, July 30, 2008

Think Before You Give A Former Employee A Reference!

(Called as a reference for a former Employee? THINK before speaking.)

The attorneys at Gross & Romaick's Business Law Division offer some advice for business owners who've been asked to give a reference for a former employee.

It is more dangerous than ever to speak with a potential employer of your former employee. The Fairfax County Circuit Court in the case of Elsami v. Global One Communications, Inc. (Fairfax County Circuit Court, Law # 174096, January 11, 1999), recently permitted a defamation action to proceed against a corporation that responded to a reference inquiry.

In the Elsami case, a former employee provided his prior employer as a reference. The employee was in a managerial position in charge of the day to day running of the business in Malaysia. When contacted by a potential new employer, the former employer is alleged to have stated that the employee "lost his temper" and "just did not fit in". The employee claims that these statements cost him the potential job, so he sued his former employer for defamation.

The Fairfax County Circuit Court is allowing the case to proceed toward trial, finding that the statements made by the former employer were statements of fact, not opinion, and could have impugned the employee's professional reputation and negatively impacted his profession by preventing him from obtaining new employment.

What is an employer to do?

Although Mr. Elsami must still prove that the statements of fact were false, the Fairfax case illustrates the danger of providing references for former employees. Any time you speak with someone about a former employee, you place yourself and your company at risk of being sued. Moreover, the distinction between permissible negative opinions and impermissible factual misstatements is too difficult to determine when giving a negative reference.

The safest route is to adopt a company policy not to provide any information beyond position held and dates of employment. Any additional information and you may find yourself in expensive litigation defending your statements.

Theoretically you could obtain a written waiver and release from your former employee before speaking with third parties. Another alternative is to only give written references directly to the employee, which they can distribute to potential employees if they so choose. The safest course is to provide no statement at all.

To seek legal counsel for your Virginia business, contact Gross & Romanick today.

Tuesday, July 1, 2008

Security Deposit Treatment in Bankruptcy

What happens to a tenant's security deposit after the tenant files bankruptcy? If rent is owned, can the landlord apply the deposit to unpaid rent?

An informal poll of area Bankruptcy Lawyers reveals a belief that a security deposit can be used as a set- off against both pre-petition damages and lease termination damages under Section 553 of the Bankruptcy Code. The set off is subject to mitigation by the landlord, including releting the premises. The safest process is to have a court grant relief from stay before applying the security deposit; but this procedure may cause a debtor to file an objection. Right or wrong, most Landlords simply keep the deposit.

Some attorneys also argued that Landlord can assert a "secured claim" up to the amount of the security deposit.

For more information contact the Business Law division of Gross & Romanick today.

Wednesday, May 14, 2008

Accounts Receivable

As part of its Business Law practice, Gross & Romanick from time to time posts articles on their website they feel may be useful to clients. A recent article, “Accounts Receivable: A Plan to Improve Your Collections,” is reprinted below.

For more information about Gross & Romanick’s Business Law practice, contact the firm at 703-273-1400.

Accounts Receivable: A Plan to Improve Your Collections

Effective management of accounts receivable requires a written procedures manual, so that the patients, the office staff and the doctors understand everyone's duties and responsibilities. This plan will increase in-house collections.

A comprehensive collection plan that informs your patients of their obligations and identifies bad debts early can go a long way toward putting you in control of your accounts-getting your money more quickly and minimizing the cases sent to an attorney or collection agency. Any such plan that you devise must strike a balance between a policy that is too harsh at the cost of strained relations, or a lost patient, and one that is too permissive at the cost of profitability. Even the best plan will prove futile in some cases, when it becomes apparent that any further effort to convince a patient to pay will fall on deaf ears. Identifying bad debts and quickly sending them out for collection will improve your success rate.

This sample outlines a mix of written and oral reminders. Perhaps one like it will work for you.

The Collection Plan: Taking Control of Your Accounts Receivable

You've completed your service for the client and sent out the bill. But the money is not yet in your hands. You could just sit and wait (and hope), but we suggest a better alternative: a collection plan. A comprehensive plan will make collections more successful by informing clients of their obligations and identifying bad debts early enough to take appropriate action.

Formulating an effective collection plan is the first and most important step in getting control of your accounts. By setting up a comprehensive scheme for dealing with accounts receivable collections, you can obtain your money faster and avoid the necessity of going to an outside collection agency or attorney.

In constructing a collection plan it is important to strike a balance between effective collections and not angering (and losing) clients. At the same time it is necessary to quickly identify those clients who will not pay, so that more drastic actions are initiated.

In order for a collection plan to be effective it must treat all accounts according to the same policy so that your staff and clients know their obligations. This consistency will can be best achieved through the creation of a "schedule", similar to the one show below, which sets out the various contacts that should be made with the debtor at appropriate intervals. When designing a schedule you need to keep diplomacy in mind as well as your financial needs. A bookkeeper can call a client to check on an account a certain amount of time after a bill has been sent. If this is done incorrectly it can be very rude and will be likely to antagonize your clients, but if it is done properly it can be both polite and effective.

The schedule show below is only an example; you will have to design your own plan to suit your particular business needs.

At some point it will become apparent that any further efforts to convince a client to disgorge the unpaid funds would be futile. The whole point of a collection plan is to determine who is not going to pay, and to determine it as quickly as possible. Our own feeling is that any account which is over 90 days past due should be considered a bad debt and sent to an attorney for collection.

Past Due Contact Type
15 days Pleasant memo: "Do you need more information?" -- written
30 days Polite inquiry: "Just a reminder." -- oral
45 days Strong reminder: "Is there a problem?" -- written/oral
60 days Strong demand: "Please pay now!" -- written/oral
75 days Final demand: "Pay now or face legal action." -- written/oral/personal visit
90 days Place debt with collection agency or attorney